We haven't made any changes to the scenario. This is an attempt to see if a more effective attack can be mounted using different tactics. I've decided to stick with the same supports - an extra Lee tank, a Red command dice and an engineer demolition team. I still feel that's a good combination for what I am attempting to achieve. As with the last game the British platoon automatically receive one Lee tank and a pre-game barrage. The Japanese have four support points and I won't discover what they are until they appear.
The patrol phase plays out in a similar fashion leaving both sides with deployment options across the table.
Unfortunately the Japanese are off to a good start with high force morale at eleven while the British are at nine. Despite that, if the British achieve a victory, I expect it to be as a result of eliminating bunkers rather than a collapse in enemy morale. I need to prevent British morale falling needlessly and one way of doing that will be to avoid a few of the errors of the last game.
The early phases of this one saw the British deploy and approach the hill ready to mount an assault. The Japanese simply watched and waited. I don't think there's any need to track those individual movements and deployments phase by phase, so I'll provide just an overview.
The two Lees were the first arrivals as they had the furthest to travel. While I wasn't expecting to see the Japanese this early in the game there was no harm having the gunners on overwatch.
The platoon's second in command, the Havildar organised a base of fire from the edge of the woods on the right flank near the hill.
The two tanks took it in turns to move flat out while the other stood on overwatch.
With the pregame barrage over the Japanese are free to deploy and an entrenched squad appears further up the hill.
They unleash all their fire at the lone scout.
By some miracle he survives, although perhaps unsurprisingly he suffers a further three points of shock.
That's enough for him and he breaks, falling back toward the woods from whence he came.
His sudden departure sees British morale drops to seven and frees up that jump-off-point for the Japanese again.
However, it turns out the Japanese are not finished with him just yet. The platoon's Gunso deploys with the entrenched squad.
He orders the MMG crew in the bunker to also target the scout.
While the covering fire does a good job of reducing some of the impact of that fire the lone soldier also proves to have a charmed life and suffers only a further point of shock.
A second Japanese squad deploys, this time they are in a prepared position near the centre of the hill.
They are to the left of the MMG bunker and for now only the LMG bunker is revealed. Somewhere close by the squad's rifle team remain concealed in their spider holes. The LMG opens fires on the 2” mortar team, but has no effect.
The platoon's grenade discharger squad also deploys.
They are situated on the hill furthest from the British and have limited line of sight.
From there they can see the 2” mortar team and send an initial round of three grenades in their direction, inflicting a point of shock.
Fortune then looks kindly on the British with a command roll of 66521(1). As is so often the case, it's a double edged sword as the command options for this phase prove limited. What it will allow me to do is try to close down the nearest jump-off-point. The Lee drives flat out towards it.
The 2” mortar team aims a round of smoke toward the MMG bunker and this time their aim is true.
The following British command roll is 66421(6), can I make the most of this opportunity? The Lee drives slowly through the jump-off-point.
It then targets the Japanese trench with a round of HE from the 75mm gun.
The Japanese prove resilient and suffer only two points of shock on the LMG team.
With the MMG bunker shrouded in smoke the Havildar seizes the opportunity to push forward the assault.
He sends one of the sections at the double out of woods towards the hill and they bypass the lone scout cowering in the open ground.
He then orders the 2” mortar team to target smoke at the LMG bunker.
Once again their aim is off.
Finally the Havildar has the nearby Bren team put down covering fire.
In the next British phase the 2” mortar team fires smoke again and this time it lands perfectly in front of the bunker.
That's put a fairly effective smoke screen in front of two of the bunkers. It has the added bonus of limiting the line of sight for the grenade discharger squad.
The Lee in the centre drives flat out toward the hill.
The other Lee unleashes a round of canister from the 37mm gun at the Japanese in the trench.
One of the LMG crew is killed and the rifle team suffer a point of shock. Rather disappointingly a round from the more powerful 75mm gun fails to do any damage at all.
In the Japanese phase I'm in for a nasty surprise. I'd grown over confident that there were no threats to my tanks and I suspect Dave knew that might be the case. While I should have seen this coming I'm utterly disheartened to see a tank hunter team burst out from the nearby jump-off-point.
It's close enough to bring the tank hunters into contact with the Lee. I think I know how this ends. Where is the tank's infantry support when they're needed?
The hollow charge is thrust against the Lee's armour and the powerful blast has little problem knocking out the tank. Fortunately it doesn't explode in flames and the crew are able to bail out. Nonetheless it takes British morale down to seven and once again I am punished for failing to provide the tanks with close infantry support.
The Gunso rallies shock off the LMG team and the Japanese squad remains firmly in place having seen off the first attack.
In the British phase the Havildar moves up to the tree line.
Once in command range he orders the section to continue pushing forward.
That brings them closer to the hill. With the support of the remaining tank and cover from the mortar smoke there's a chance for them to close with the bunkers.
The Lee moves up the hill going flat out.
The engineer demolition team are called forward and they deploy into the tree line.
In the Japanese phase the Gunso rallies the last remaining point of shock off the squad in the trench. He then orders the LMG team to fire.
They are the only men under his command with a line of sight to the advancing British.
They target the section's rifle team and kill one of the men.
The Gocho then puts the entrenched squad's rifle team on overwatch.
The LMG bunker may be blinded by smoke but the squad's rifle team open fire from their spider holes.
The British section find themselves caught in a crossfire from Japanese positions.
The result is deadly. Another rifleman is killed, as is the Naik, the section's commander. That's a real blow and I decide to use a CoC die to avoid a potentially hard hit to force morale.
While the loss of the Naik is a setback I'm determined to continue pushing the assault ahead. A command roll of 44321(2) really helps and demonstrates the tactical value of a red command dice. The Jemadar deploys with a section from the central jump-off-point right in front of the hill.
The Jemadar takes command of the rifle team and orders them to fire five rounds rapid at the spider holes.
One of the Japanese riflemen is killed.
The section's Naik then works with the Bren team. He has them use concentrated fire to focus all their attention on the same team of Japanese riflemen. The Bren does the job and kills the remaining two men.
The section without the Naik charges toward the other spider holes, but they fail to close with the enemy.
The Havildar orders the 2” mortar team to fire one of their limited rounds of HE at the spider holes but it fails to have any effect on the occupants.
He then orders the nearby section to fire on the same target.
That inflicts a couple of points of shock, reducing their already limited firepower.
Last, he sends the demolition engineers forward.
Up on the hill the Lee targets the entrenched Japanese with both canister and HE.
The tank fire has proved disappointing and this is no different, inflicting only two points of shock.
In the Japanese phase the riflemen in the spider holes shoot at the oncoming section, but with only two fire dice it's little surprise the fire is ineffective.
Once again the Gunso is quick to rally shock from the men in the trench.
The grenade discharger squad fire an initial volley at the Jemadar and his section but has no effect.
The second of the Japanese prepared positions appears near the jump-off-point on the far side of the hill.
Both the LMG in the bunker and riflemen in the spider holes open fire. They too target the section with the Jemadar.
Their fire proves more effective than that from the grenade discharger squad and a rifleman is killed.
In the British phase the Havildar orders the section near him to maintain their fire at the spider holes.
The Japanese suffer more shock and that's enough to see them pinned down.
The Havildar then runs forward to give directions to the leaderless section.
He urges them on to assault the spider holes.
The Japanese are in no position to stand and fight. The odds are greater than 4 to 1 and they fall back immediately suffering twelve points of shock.
That's more than enough to see them break and continue retreating toward the back of the table.
Despite that Japanese morale holds steady.
The Jemadar presses forward with his section having them move at the double towards the hill.
Once there he rallies off a point of shock and brings the men back to order.
With his last command initiative he directs the 2” mortar team to fire smoke on the LMG bunker that recently appeared. It's off target but does succeed in covering one of the teams in the spider holes.
Anything that limits Japanese firepower while the sections are moving toward the hill is a good thing and I'll take whatever I can get.
The Lee continues firing on the entrenched squad. This time they suffer another casualty and shock on both teams.
In the Japanese phase first the grenade discharger squad and then the LMG bunker and spider holes pour fire at the section with the Jemadar.
One of the Bren team is killed and the section suffers five points of shock. The Japanese are determined to drive off the infantry.
The Gocho rallies a point of shock before ordering the squad forward out of the trench. Realising there is little to be gained from sitting under the guns of the Lee and taking continuous punishment Dave decides to take the initiative and seek out the British infantry. Unfortunately they move far less quickly than he would have liked.
Seizing the chance to catch the Japanese moving in open ground I interrupt using a CoC die and have the Lee fire its co-axial machine gun.
It's another disappointing performance from the tankers. The machine gun manages a single hit which results in a point of shock.
However I have no grounds for complaint. The following British command roll is 663331 and I can certainly try to make the most of that. First the Lee uses its last round of canister and a round of HE from the 75 to fire at the advancing Japanese.
The fire fails to inflict any casualties but it does see the squad's shock start to build.
The Jemadar rallies two points of shock from the section he's attached to.
He uses his last command initiative to order the section to his right to move up to the MMG bunker.
They approach from outside the bunker's firing arc and work their way into position to assault the fortification with grenades.
The Naik with the section accompanying the Jemadar rallies another point of shock and leads the men up the hill.
They follow him more slowly than he would like.
However the British have the next phase and a good command roll of 65441(2) means the assault can continue to push forward. The Havildar moves up to stay within command range of the section at the MMG bunker.
He uses his remaining two command initiatives to have the men 'post' grenades into the bunker's aperture.
Both grenades are sent in and the resulting explosions are catastrophic for the occupants. The entire machine gun team is wiped out and the bunker neutralised.
The Jemadar rallies off a couple of points of shock from the section he is with prior to having them move toward the other bunker.
At this point I'm in two minds as to whether the men move only as far as the aperture of the bunker or whether I should attempt close combat. In the end I decide on close combat, if only to see how those rules play out and whether it is more or less effective than posting grenades (although after the results just seen it's hard to see how it could be any more effective!). The one thing it could be is far more immediate. If I can wipe out the occupants in this current phase then the scenario is won. If on the other hand I wait until a following phase to post grenades who knows whether that gives the Japanese an opportunity to counter attack?
The section has no problem covering the distance to the bunker's rear door and into close combat.
While the rules specify this is treated as though the defenders are in hard cover we decided the Japanese LMG would not be factored into the calculation as this was outside its arc of fire. At the same time we didn't think this would constitute an attack from the rear, so that was not included. We also weren't sure whether to factor in the number of movement dice used by the attacker given the slightly unusual nature of the approach to contact, but included it anyway.
A fairly bloody round of combat ensues. The British inflict heavy losses on the occupants but not enough to wipe them out. The Gocho is wounded and three of the four LMG crew are killed. However the defenders sell their lives dearly. The British lose five men, including the Naik who is killed.
Having been repulsed the British are pushed back down the hill, their morale falling to five.
The Lee moves normally toward the Japanese squad hoping to take advantage of their shock and scatter them.
It doesn't move fast enough to contact the whole squad but enough to plough towards the rifle team.
They manage to avoid the tank's tracks and make an escape.
They continue moving down the hill but that divides the squad and leaves the LMG team behind (this raises a rules interpretation - the Japanese characteristic
Stay Close means the squad's teams must always stay within 4" of each other, so under these circumstances I'm uncertain whether the LMG team is dragged along by the fleeing rifle team or must move separately to rejoin the squad in a later phase? For now we kept them separate).
In the Japanese phase the Gocho rallies shock and leads the men against the nearest British section.
The odds certainly don't favour the Japanese. This is no more than a desperate attempt to drive down British morale before the bunkers are eliminated. Unfortunately things don't work out well for them. The British drive them off with their Bren gun and submachine guns, inflicting six casualties and three shock while they themselves lose only two men and suffer a single point of shock.
The Gocho is one of the casualties and he is wounded. However the losses have left the two leaders leading a single soldier and having been defeated in close combat they break and fall back 18".
The survivors of the British section stand and hold their ground. They may have lost their Naik but they have continued to soldier on valiantly without him, taking out the MMG bunker and driving off the Japanese squad.
With no enemy in line of sight the Havildar is able to rally off their shock.
The Jemadar then sends the three remaining men of the section with him to the aperture of the LMG bunker.
They will be in position to post grenades in their next phase but the Jemadar hopes that won't be necessary. He calls over the men from the section who drove off the Japanese squad.
He joins them at the rear door of the bunker in an attempt to finish off the occupants once and for all.
It proves enough to do the job, killing the Gocho and wiping out the remainder of the LMG team. The Jemadar is wounded in the process but it matters little, his men have eliminated a second Japanese bunker and that's enough to secure victory for this scenario.
At the end of the previous game I expressed my opinion that it was not the tanks that were the bunker busters it was the infantry and so this game has proven. In fact that one rifle section can take credit for much of the effort. Despite losing their section commander they went on to wipe out a team in spider holes; destroy an MMG bunker in a grenade attack; drive off a Japanese squad in close combat and, last but not least, deliver the coup de grace to one of the LMG bunkers. They're made of stern stuff.
That was a much more satisfying game for the British and I'm pleased we were not too hasty in making any changes to the scenario based on the initial game. It still remains tough for the British but by no means impossible. A combined arms attack certainly reaped better rewards than one overly reliant on a single arm.
One thought on playing the Japanese in this setting. In the first game Dave was successful using a fairly linear defence and concentrating as much fire as possible on the British infantry as they tried to approach the hill. That worked well in that situation, mainly because I played into his hands. I wonder if the Japanese should give thought to a defence with more depth given only one fortification can deploy from each jump-off-point? Until it could be suppressed or blinded by smoke I felt the entrenched squad at the back of the bunkers was effectively positioned to cover the approaches and protect the rear.
While the Japanese don't want to be outflanked I wonder if a more compact position with bunkers and entrenched infantry offer depth and mutual support would make for a more difficult position to break? Perhaps two jump-off-points forward and one back or vice versa? It would depend on circumstances but it certainly gives me some food for thought about how a Japanese defence might be woven together.
That finishes our play test of the campaign. Dave and I will share some thoughts and notes on any final adjustments we feel need to be made before we try to find a way to have this published and made available to more people.
